Even as violence remains at frighteningly high levels on Rikers Island, the New York City Council is moving to handicap the City’s Department of Correction (DOC), making it all but impossible to control unruly prisoners within the city’s jails.

A bill floated by liberal City Council members and expected to pass with a veto-proof majority has been presented by supporters as a ban on the use of solitary confinement and a move toward an “evidence-based” approach to detention. But at a hearing on the bill Wednesday, the DOC maintained that it would make the city’s jail even more dangerous, with Commissioner Louis Molina suggesting that it would increase violence “exponentially.”

Molina is right. While the bill is framed as a solitary confinement ban (a practice which is already essentially illegal), it would substantially limit the ability of DOC to control the hundreds of people who assault guards and other inmates each year.

The bill’s “ban” on solitary confinement is really a broad guarantee of out-of-cell time—14 hours a day. Individuals can be locked in their cell for more than two hours only “to de-escalate immediate conflict that has caused injury or poses a specific, serious and imminent danger to a person’s safety,” and even that confinement can last no more than four hours. It’s all a far cry from solitary confinement, which Amnesty International defines as 22 to 24 hours of in-cell time a day.

The “ban” is less important, however, than the bill’s constraints on the use of “restrictive housing”—stricter detention that serves as a consequence for offenses committed within jail house walls. Specifically, it would prohibit placing someone in restrictive housing until the Board of Correction finds they have committed a “Violent Grade I” offense. If an inmate slashes another, in other words, he couldn’t be moved out of the general population until he received a full hearing, with legal representation.

The bill also significantly limits DOC’s ability to discourage misconduct. It stipulates that DOC “shall use positive incentives to encourage good behavior in restrictive housing units and may use disciplinary sanctions only as a last resort in response to behavior presenting a serious and evident danger after other measures have not alleviated such behavior.” In other words, DOC would be bound to an all-carrot, no-stick approach to managing dangerous detainees.

Long-term solitary confinement is already illegal under New York State law. The HALT Act, passed last year by the state legislature, prohibits holding someone in restrictive housing for longer than 15 days, and prohibits its use entirely for those aged 21 and under, 55 and older, and with certain disabilities. The bill also guarantees even those in restrictive housing four hours of out-of-cell programming—a standard adopted by the DOC in 2019.

New York City jails are already remarkably chaotic. The federal monitor overseeing Rikers Island recently reported that there were nearly 190 stabbings and slashings in the first four months of 2022 alone—an 89 percent increase over the same period in 2021. There were also 265 assaults on staff, down 25 percent from the same period in 2021, but virtually unchanged from 2016, when the monitor was first installed to respond to the system’s level of violence.

These high rates of violence are a function both of the challenges of running the system—including extremely high rates of absenteeism among staff—and of the population it detains. Of the roughly 5,200 pretrial detainees in DOC custody on Tuesday (the most recent day available), more than half were in for violent offenses; more than 1,000 were thought to be members of prison gangs. Even in a well-functioning system, the potential for violence would be high.

The new bill would significantly deprive DOC of one of its main tools for managing this risk. The prohibition on prehearing detention, though operating under the guise of due process, protects the right of violent detainees to victimize those around them, both other prisoners and staff. Even when individuals get placed in restrictive housing—an unlikely prospect, given the long procedure that would be imposed on placement—DOC has few means with which to compel their compliance with jail rules.

Everyone, including Molina, agrees that New York City’s jails are broken and dangerous. But it’s contradictory to decry that danger while embracing these changes. Hopefully, the council will see the error of its ways, and drop its plan to stop DOC from keeping guards and detainees alike safe.

Photo: Rawf8/iStock


City Journal is a publication of the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research (MI), a leading free-market think tank. Are you interested in supporting the magazine? As a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, donations in support of MI and City Journal are fully tax-deductible as provided by law (EIN #13-2912529).

Further Reading

Up Next